black market labor
This article on our black market labor situation (not even considering the stuff about pot and porn) got me thinking . I have a kneejerk reaction to tell people to hire day laborers - merely because they are so desperate for work. I know it is problematic, but haven't really tried to think it through. And with babysitting? I did come to the conclusion that it was wrong to pay someone less than the going rate just because they were a recent immigrant and will take any job. Maybe you are thinking libertarian style, "It's not wrong, you offer, they are free to accept or not". However, I am more prone to think, "Of course it's wrong. It's unethical to take advantage of other people - in this case bad immigration laws and worker protection laws, unstable world economy, the person's lack of information about how much their work is worth, etc."
It has been odd to watch my "Of course it's wrong!" war with my "$15 an hour for babysitting, I must cough this up??"
And even worse, underneath all that, thinking "And of course childraising actually SHOULD be paid more if society valued it correctly." If I really wanted someone else to contribute to raising my kid then it seems like they should be part of the family, or neighborhood, or co-op or group marriage. Co-op of my dreams, I have certainly failed you.
M.'s nanny for a year and a half is just not in touch with us anymore really. I wish she would be... She did love him but she also has a huge extended family of her own and plenty of other problems to think about, like, what happens if I go back to Brazil with my linguistics degree and there's no jobs? I'm sure I was irritating to work for, in my own special way, but I had to be better than some of those other yuppie hose beasts who try to make her wash dishes and yell at her and accuse her of weird things like stealing a paper towel. (I'm not kidding! She dried her hands and was told she had stolen a paper towel!) I was like "okay, I've just given you a third of the money I made, a third to taxes, and then I get some. That seems okay. Meanwhile my kid is being brought up by someone who knows how to enjoy playing with babies 8 hours a day, or so she claimed consistently! Some people really do! I draw the line at believing that anyone enjoys cleaning my house, though.
When her sister-in-law came once to pick up M. with her husband and kid and there was only one car seat. And she put my kid in the car seat! And hers up in the front seat between her and husband! I freaked out. Oh no. That was one of those major disconnect moments when you realize you have no idea what is going through another person's head. Okay, in Brazil you just drive around with kids not bucked in, as I was raised, rattling around in the back or front of station wagons, vans, and pickups. But things are different now! I explain in bad spanish that it's the law. She didn't know that ... just thought the whole car seat thing was a yuppie fad to roll your eyes at!
It is better now that he has school and jhk and I are at home to pick him up and play with him. But if i have another kid, am I going to be able to deal with that first year? Maybe a half time babysitting? To have days, weeks, months go by where I'm not producing anything but milk, mystery novels used very roughly, and bitching about not enough sleep. Will it be different magically the 2nd time around? Or better because I have friends who will babysit?
Truly I used to think it startlingly wrong to hire someone else to clean my house. I first encountered this when visiting my friend A.'s apartment in some high rise in greenwich village (1st time in new york). Lo and behold "their maid" was in there cleaning. I was appalled and felt really uncomfortable to be around these scary rich people.
From a later perspective I began to think "Well, her mom had some fancy job at the UN and her dad worked somewehre else and they had a bad commute and so get up, go to work, come back 12 hours later, if they cleaned the house they'd have no time for anything else"
Of course Louise "our maid" also had to commute to her cleaning jobs, all across town, with no benefits, on the bus no less, and then go home to her own family - and then clean her own house . Guess she didn't have time to do much else, no leisure time and tickets to broadway plays and visits to the symphony like A.'s parents. The general unfairness of it all doesn't let up its grip on me. If the divide were not quite so great, I could handle there not being total fairness.
Now that I am on that cooking-cleaning-childcaring end of the stick, not only do I suck at it, but I don't even get a paycheck. Social security statements of the future will have big fat zeros on these years. jhk suddenly locked into heinous unpleasant 'responsible provider' role.
Meanwhile when I want some furniture moved or stuff hauled out of my yard I feel obliged to go pick up some guys on the street (last time they were crawling over each other, fighting to get in the car) and pay them 10 bucks an hour which is actually overpay and drive them back and they go back out on the street to join the hundreds of men in baseball hats waiting in small groups eyeing my pickup truck like it's the holy grail and I'm going, Is that 20 bucks going to actually help you any? What is your rent? Is your family here or waiting for you to bring them over? Are you okay? But I can't say any of this even with bad spanish because it's just "cuantas horas". 2. "2" "Dos" "Okay." When they go home, father and nephew, is their 40 bucks welcomed? Desperately needed? Did I just help them? Is it too small an amount to even matter, a drop in the bucket to their rent? Where to even begin to attack the root of this one small symptom? Don't shoot me, but as soon as you start thinking about social inequalities and wealth doesn't it just torment you?
I don't know what it is with these post-sleeping pill writing sessions, I get started and can't stop though my eyes are barely open and I feel about 100 iq points dumber and number than normal.